Showing posts with label Chrysler. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chrysler. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

What to do about corporate bail outs?

You are right that we are in an enormous catch 22. No, the government does not have the money and if they print it, inflation will be rampant, the dollar will dive and we could see a loaf of bread costing $25!

But this does clarify the risk. I am just as ideologically against corporate bail out as anyone - they deserve to pay for their mistakes - that is the risk they took. But, due to uncontrolled and rampant corporate borrowing, their debt is so great that those holding the bag would fold - ultimately that means the entire financial sector.

Imagine what it would be like if there was no credit at all available. Understanding leverage (the ability to borrow), one can turn a dollar into 10 - this is the engine of our economy. For example: if you needed to buy a house for $200k, and you had the cash, then you are golden. You now own $200k in real estate. But, with leverage, finding an 80% LTV loan, you could now finance and buy five $200k houses. You now own $1 million in real estate for the same $200k investment. Someone built those homes, someone made the materials for the builder, someone sold the land, someone made a commission, someone paid taxes and impact fees, someone provides on-going services to the properties - all of these people make an income and can now buy their own homes. Then, if you put tenants in those homes for a rent amount that is more than your expenses, then you generate more income to invest in future homes. Your $200k has gone a long way!

But, without financing, your holdings are limited to one house and you have now cut the jobs of all of those involved in the other 4 homes.

Likewise, if corporate debt financing (bonds) fail, bond insurers (AIG, etc) will also fail, backers of the bonds will no longer invest (China, sovereign nation funds, pension funds, institutional investors, general public, etc.), there will be no more financing, there will be no more growth. Taken to the far extreme, GM would only be able to make one car at a time and not begin another until that one sold!

So what is the solution? I don't know. There are people smarter than me (I hope) working on this. But there should be some pain for these corporations: No bonuses, no dividends, all profits go either into growth or repayment, with at lease a large percentage going to repayment; Execs cut their exorbitant pay, no golden parachutes, the government gets collateral (this borders on socialism and scares me too), The unions have to give in. Maybe we form a new chapter in the bankruptcy code which allows the corporation to suspend union contracts and delay unnecessary debt repayment - like chapter 11 reorganization, but not insolvency.

Learn form the mistakes, though. The bond debt was under insured by the likes of AIG and because of deregulation, there was not transparency to show that the insurers were overexposed – they were able to hide the problems while inviting more people to invest (read “Credit Default Swaps”). We must have clear oversight and demand accountability, regulation, and protection.

But, keep in mind that there is more pain ahead. As we decrease our spending - which we should do since personal debt is at an all-time high - the economy will slow further. Consumers account for 80% of the economy. This could indeed lead to deflation - those 75 cent beers you want - but that too has its perils - namely standard of living will fall because incomes will also fall.

So - do we have the answer? Probably not. For now, make sure your seat belt is fastened, keep your arms and legs in the car at all times and pray we do not run out of gas.

Peace!